In large-scale digital transformation and software implementation projects, a common challenge for businesses is the proliferation of software requirements from various departments. Each department and individual naturally has their own desires and ideas for improving their work. While understandable, if not rigorously managed, this can lead to significant budget overruns, extended project timelines, redundant or insufficient software features, and ultimately, a failure to achieve desired outcomes.
According to McKinsey (2022), over 70% of digital transformation projects fall short of expectations. Panorama Consulting (2021) also reported that 54% of ERP projects run over time or budget, and up to 21% fail entirely. While specific reasons vary, the common denominators include:
- Lack of clear criteria to evaluate and prioritize software requirements
- Departments pursuing their own objectives, leading to misalignment
- Implementation decisions driven by emotion or internal politics
To help businesses navigate tough choices - such as which features to build, which requests are essential, and which are merely "nice-to-haves" - we apply the Viindoo KPI-Based Design method to focus resources on what truly creates value.
What is Viindoo KPI-Based Design Methodology?
Viindoo KPI-based design is a proprietary methodology developed by Viindoo to measure and assess the effectiveness of digital transformation initiatives.
From software design, features, tools, to implementation methods - everything revolves around the principle of “measurable design.” This ensures that every implementation action aligns with specific objectives and measurable outcomes.
Unlike traditional approaches that rely on gut feeling or vague functional descriptions, Viindoo KPI-Based Design helps:
- Define project KPIs and measurable metrics to help businesses clearly track progress, quality, and investment outcomes
- Align technology systems with business goals
- Optimize resources by prioritizing based on impact and effort
- Establish a unified direction across departments and the entire project - grounded in data
Viindoo KPI-Based Design is not a theoretical concept. It is grounded in over 20 years of practical experience in implementing management software across various industries and business sizes. It is also informed by global research on common reasons for failure in ERP and digital transformation projects.
This methodology combines three practical analytical tools: requirements prioritization using MoSCoW, Return on Investment (ROI) calculation, and the Impact-Effort Matrix.
MoSCOW
(Must-have, Should-have, Could-have, Won't-have)
This is a prioritization framework for requirements. It clearly defines which features are mandatory for system operation, which are important but not immediately essential, and which can be eliminated or postponed.
ROI
(Return on Investment)
This tool quantifies the financial benefits a software feature delivers relative to its development cost. Calculating ROI provides businesses with a clear understanding of the economic value each requirement can generate.
Impact-Effort Matrix
This tool helps assess the balance between the potential value (Impact) a feature delivers and the resources required (Effort) to develop and implement it. This is a key factor in selecting solutions that yield the highest efficiency with optimal cost and effort.
When analyzed using the KPI-based design methodology, each software requirement is evaluated across three dimensions: Necessity (MoSCOW), ROI, and Impact-Effort balance. These parameters are then visualized using a "bubble chart," facilitating easy decision-making.
Applying the Viindoo KPI-Based Design to control costs & optimize software investment efficiency
Viindoo KPI-Based Design is not just a design tool.
It is the backbone of every consulting and implementation project. The process is applied through clearly defined steps
MoSCoW Requirements Prioritization
In this phase, the Viindoo project team collaborates with stakeholders to categorize requirements based on their criticality:
These are indispensable features required for the system to function or to meet legal and regulatory compliance. Without these features, the project cannot succeed, or the system cannot operate.
Score: 7 - 8 points
These features are highly important, offering significant value, but are not strictly necessary for the initial phase. They can be prioritized for development after "Must-have" features.
Score: 5 - 6 points
These are desirable features that could enhance user experience or improve efficiency, but they are not high-priority. They are only considered if sufficient resources and time are available.
Score: 3 - 4 points
These features are identified as unnecessary or misaligned with project objectives and will be excluded from the scope.
Score: 1 - 2 points
This classification ensures focus on the most critical requirements and prevents waste on non-essential features.
ROI (Return on Investment)
Following prioritization, the next step involves calculating the financial benefits each feature yields compared to its development cost. This demands a thorough analysis of associated costs (development, implementation, maintenance) and anticipated benefits (revenue increase, operational cost reduction, productivity enhancement, error reduction).
A feature might be "hot" or align with a technology trend, but if its ROI is low or negative, it may not be the optimal choice. Calculating ROI transforms decisions from subjective to quantitative, based on concrete data and figures.
>>>> Read more: ROI analysis process at Viindoo
Impact-Effort Matrix
The Impact-Effort Matrix measures a feature's systemic impact. Specifically, it considers:
Impact
This dimension quantifies the potential positive outcome or value that the initiative will bring. It answers the question, "How much good will this do?" High impact can mean increased revenue, reduced costs, improved customer satisfaction, enhanced efficiency, strategic alignment, or better risk mitigation. To ensure consistent and comparable impact assessment across all requirements, Viindoo uses the following impact scoring scale:
- 9 - 10 points: Strong impact - brings significant, company-wide changes
- 6 - 8 points: Moderate impact - helps optimize workflows
- 3 - 5 points: Minor impact - supports a few departments
- 1 - 2 points: Minimal impact - little to no noticeable effect
Effort
This dimension quantifies the resources, time, and complexity required to execute the initiative. It answers the question, "How difficult or costly will this be to achieve?" High effort typically involves significant time commitment, large financial investment, a high number of personnel, complex technical challenges, or considerable organizational change. Viindoo uses a standardized scoring scale within the KPI-Based Design method to quantify effort levels:
- 1 - 2 points: Very easy to implement, requires minimal resources, can be done immediately
- 3 - 5 points: Moderate complexity, requires coordination, involves some level of difficulty
- 6 - 8 points: High complexity, involves multiple departments, requires thorough testing
- 9 - 10 points: Very complex, high risk, demands significant time and resource investment
By plotting initiatives on a matrix with Impact on one axis and Effort on the other, teams can categorize and prioritize tasks into quadrants, for example:
- High Impact, Low Effort (Quick Wins): These are often top priorities, as they deliver significant value with minimal resources.
- High Impact, High Effort (Major Projects): These are strategic initiatives that require careful planning and resource allocation due to their high value.
- Low Impact, Low Effort (Fill-ins): These are less critical tasks that can be done when resources are available, but shouldn't distract from higher-impact work.
- Low Impact, High Effort (Thankless Tasks): These should generally be avoided or reconsidered, as they consume many resources for little return.
The Impact-Effort Matrix helps teams make data-informed decisions, allocate resources effectively, and focus on initiatives that provide the best return on investment of time and resources.
For large-scale or high-risk projects, Viindoo incorporates additional frameworks to increase decision confidence:
- ISO 31000:2018 Risk Management: Identifies and mitigates implementation risks
- Viindoo 7DX Digital Maturity Framework: Assesses organizational readiness and identifies operational bottlenecks to be addressed with technology
These methods are integrated throughout Viindoo Digital Transformation Strategy Consulting and Implementation Services.
Bubble Chart Visualization in Viindoo KPI-Based Design
To visualize analysis results and support fast decision-making, the Viindoo KPI-Based Design method utilizes a bubble chart, which simultaneously displays three core factors on a two-dimensional plane:
- The Y-axis represents the Impact level, from low to high
- The X-axis represents the Return on Investment (ROI), from low to high
- The bubble size reflects the implementation effort - the larger the bubble, the greater the effort required
“Must-have” requirements are marked with distinct colors (e.g., red), making it easy for users to identify mandatory features, even if their ROI or Impact is not immediately prominent.
Visualizing the Viindoo KPI-Based Design Method with a Bubble Chart
Using this chart, businesses can easily identify and make informed decisions, for example:
- Top right, small bubble (High ROI, High Impact, Low Effort): Prioritize immediate implementation. These are the "golden features" that deliver the highest value with minimal resource investment.
- Top right, large bubble (High ROI, High Impact, High Effort): These are major strategic initiatives that should be prioritized, but require careful planning due to high resource demands. They are best suited for medium- to long-term implementation with strong executive commitment. Viindoo refers to these as “Big Bets” or “High-Stake Items.”
- Bottom left, large bubble (Low ROI, Low Impact, High Effort): Consider eliminating or postponing these, as they consume significant resources with minimal return.
- “Must-have” bubbles: Regardless of position on the chart, these must be included in the implementation roadmap due to their critical nature.
The bubble chart not only provides leadership and project teams with a clear, comprehensive overview, but also facilitates alignment on priorities across all stakeholders - grounded in data, not subjective opinion. It is one of the signature tools of the Viindoo KPI-Based Design implementation system.
Practical Benefits for Businesses
Implementing the Viindoo KPI-based design methodology brings numerous practical and sustainable benefits for businesses:
- Cost Optimization: By eliminating redundant or ineffective requirements, businesses avoid paying for unnecessary features. This helps control budgets and maximize the efficiency of every investment dollar.
- Ensured Effectiveness: This methodology helps businesses focus precisely on what truly drives business results. Every software development effort is directed towards improving key KPIs and achieving strategic objectives.
- Increased Consensus: When every requirement is analyzed based on objective criteria such as KPIs and ROI, achieving alignment among leadership, business units, and the implementation team becomes significantly easier. Everyone shares a common understanding of each feature's value and priority.
- Reduced Implementation Time: Because everything is standardized and prioritized clearly from the outset, the software development and deployment process proceeds more smoothly, minimizing unexpected modifications and escalations. This enables businesses to quickly put the product into use and reap benefits.
Evaluating all customer feature requests and development needs using the Viindoo KPI-Based Design methodology is a standard process across all ERP Implementation, Strategy Consulting, and Digital Transformation projects at Viindoo. This ensures that every requirement is backed by clear, quantifiable metrics and directly tied to business outcomes.
We have a team of seasoned experts who not only provide the methodology but also work alongside businesses through every step of implementation. From stakeholder interviews, process modeling, identifying key performance indicators, to designing a detailed feature list and budget estimation - everything is executed methodically and practically, not just left at theoretical recommendations.
Conclusion
Investing in software is not merely a technological decision - it is a strategic one, tied to business performance and resource optimization. Therefore, if your organization is preparing for a structured digital transformation or an ERP system rollout, don’t begin with gut feelings or siloed departmental demands. Start with a well-structured requirement list - designed based on data, KPIs, and clear business goals.
The Viindoo KPI-Based Design method ensures that every software investment is well-founded, and every feature developed delivers real, measurable value.
Connect with our experts
for consultation on enterprise management software solutions and discover how we can help you optimize your software projects!
